ANP001. A CHOICE OF A PERSPECTIVE SYSTEM FOR VIBRATION ISOLATION IN CONDITIONS OF VARYING ENVIRONMENT

The report consider the application of AHP and ANP for prediction of probable modifications of the factors, which mainly influence a choice of a type of vibration isolation system for the manufacturing. Similar tasks take place in the problems of external designing, when it is necessary to make decision being effective in varying environment. ANP technique gives limiting impact priorities for influential factors when the experts' preferences are constant. AHP technique with use of the dynamic judgments enables to find out the tendencies of priorities changes based on the dynamic experts judgments, which are given by defined functions of time. The obtained outcomes are consistent and supplement each other.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,dynamic judgments,external designing,JURNAL ANP,limiting priority,supermatrix

Mengintegrasikan DPSIR dengan Analytic Network Process untuk penilaian strategi pengelolaan hutan. (E 18211-10 anp)

The application of the DPSIR evaluation scheme is processing a holistic view on the performance of forest management strategies with pressures driven by external forces influencing the actual states of a forest and their impacts over time, yet to be antagonized by management responses. Covering all this, the overall results of the ANP evaluation show an undisputed favour of the conversion strategy for all time steps and climate change scenarios with regard to the principles of SFM. A transformation of the present conifer plantations dominated by Norway Spruce to more close-to-nature forests by introducing and pre-planting deciduous tree species is promising on the long run.
Hence, it has been the rationale of this study to combine the strengths of tools that enhance system understanding and those of multi-criteria decision making for the purposes of SFM while keeping the whole concept at least semi-quantitative by integrating ecosystem modelling results. This integration creates new viewpoints towards the communication of decision-making, towards the relations between ecosystem and decision-modelling, and towards the applicability of established approaches per se.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,DPSIR,JURNAL ANP,PENGELOLAAN HUTAN,SFM

Potensi dan keterbatasan analisis metode multi-kriteria dalam menilai pengelolaan hutan lestari. (E 182011-9)

European commitments towards sustainable forest management (SFM) are well established at the political level. However, progress in implementing the principles of SFM at the operational scale lags behind. As an option to foster this process, the application of indicators within a multi-criteria analysis (MCA) framework is proposed.
In this contribution, Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique (SMART), the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), the Analytic Network Process (ANP), PROMETHEE I/II and ELECTRE III are applied to assess the performances of four management units representing different forestry regimes within a region. A recently developed set of indicators at forest management unit level is used in the analysis.
The implementation of SFM requires a holistic view on multiple goals and values, the awareness of uncertain and inhomogeneous knowledge, the guidance of stakeholder involvement and a spatially explicit long-term perspective. Against this background, the potentials and limits of each MCA method to assess SFM are compared with regard to (i) handling preferences and trade-offs between indicators, (ii) sensitivity in covering complex information on the human-ecosystem interaction, (iii) dealing with thresholds and uncertainty of value information, (iv) participatory planning and group decision making processes, and (v) communicative features.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,ELECTRE III,JURNAL ANP,MULTI KRITERIA,PENGELOLAAN HUTAN LESTARI,PROMETHEE,SMART

ALAT PENDUKUNG KEPUTUSAN UNTUK ANALISIS KEBIJAKAN STRATEGIS. (E 182011-8 anp)

New or improved decision analysis tools are developed in this thesis to address strategic policy analysis with specific focus on two topics: strategic conflict analysis and region-performance comparisons.

A strategic conflict refers to a situation in which two or more decision makers (DMs) are to make a decision that affects issues over which they have different preferences. Various forms of strategic conflict exist all around us, in areas such as environmental management, international relations, economic competition, and relationships among individuals. The graph model for conflict resolution (GMCR) is an advanced and comprehensive tool to systematically study strategic conflicts. A well-known decision tool, the analytic network process (ANP) is adapted for use in strategic conflict analysis and a comparison of the performance of ANP with GMCR is carried out. Both methods are applied to an international trading conflict between the United States and China over the importation of television sets into the US in order to gain strategic insights about this dispute using the two different but complementary approaches.

A country’s overall performance comparison with respect to different kinds of indices such as economic, environmental and political indices constitutes another interesting topic for strategic policy analysis. An index aggregation approach is proposed to compare BRICSAM countries, a populous rapidly-growing economic group of nations consisting of Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, ASEAN (Association of South-East Asian Nations), and Mexico with G7 (Group of Seven), the most developed country club including Canada, France, Italy, Japan, Germany, United Kingdom and the United States. A data-envelopment-analysis (DEA) based approach is proposed to aggregate different ranking indices for BRICSAM and the G7 countries. The proposed method can provide a fair overall assessment of a country’s standing by maximizing its possibility of obtaining the best evaluation score.

Finally, a framework to carry out generic strategic analysis for regions’ competence analysis is designed based upon the theory of generic strategic analysis proposed by Porter (1980). This is a well-known approach for use in business competence analysis. The basic idea is to carry out generic strategic analysis in policy studies and two decision tools, DEA and the analytic hierarchy process, are employed to quantify the analysis of competence efficiency and potentiality, respectively. A case study of the competence analysis of provinces in China is used to demonstrate the analysis procedure.

Read more »

Posted in: ALAT PENDUKUNG KEPUTUSAN,ANALISIS KEBIJAKAN STRATEGIS,ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,RESOLUSI KONFLIK

Merancang sistem kelompok pendukung keputusan di bawah ketidakpastian menggunakan Grup Fuzzy Analytic Network Process. (E 182011-7 anp)

Handling uncertainty in decision making is recently receiving considerable attention by researchers. Advances in group Fuzzy analytic network process (ANP) are discussed to support decision making because of the complexity and vagueness under uncertainty. An adaptive group Fuzzy ANP group decision support system (DSS) under uncertainty is put forth that makes up for some deficiencies in the conventional ANP. Fuzzy judgments are firstly used when it is difficult to characterize the uncertainty by point-valued judgments due to partially known information, and a bipartite graph is formulated to model the problem of group decision making under uncertainty. Then, a Fuzzy prioritization method is proposed to derive the local priorities from missing or inconsistent Fuzzy pairwise comparison judgments. As a result of the unlikeliness for all the decision makers to evaluate all elements under uncertainty, an original aggregation method is developed to cope with the situation where some of the local priorities are missing. Finally, an evaluation of petroleum contaminated site remedial countermeasures using the proposed group Fuzzy ANP, indicates that the presented group DSS can effectively handle uncertainty and support group decision making with high level of user satisfaction

Kata kunci: Kelompok pendukung keputusan, ketidakpastian, proses jaringan analitik, kelompok ANP Fuzzy, agregasi, situs perbaikan penanggulangan.

Read more »

Posted in: AGREGASI,ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,GRUP FUZZY ANP,JURNAL ANP,KELOMPOK PENDUKUNG KEPUTUSAN,KETIDAKPASTIAN

Alat Evaluasi Mengidentifikasi Implikasi Perubahan Iklim dan Pembangunan Ekonomi Keberlanjutan (E 182011-6 anp)

Research on developing well designed evaluation tools will provide the information and understanding necessary for identifying more effective adaptation options and better management plans for ensuring regional sustainability. This paper presents an integrated approach that integrates ecosystem vulnerability identification, adaptation option evaluation, and multi-stakeholder participation. The integrated approach will be applied in Lijiang and Yulong Mountain region of China for identifying desirable resource management plans to reduce ecosystem vulnerabilities. Different computer- and non-model based methods will be adopted to form the integrated approach. The research starts with data collection and the identification of vulnerabilities of ecosystems and economic sectors to climate and socio-economic changes. This is followed by survey and interviews that allow stakeholders to participate in a multi-criteria evaluation of adaptation options. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP), an MCDM technique, will be employed as an adaptation evaluation tool to rank desirability of resource management plans. The paper will provide some articulation on how the integrated approach can provide an effective mean for the synthetic evaluation of the general desirability levels of a set of resource management plans through a multi-criteria and multi- stakeholder decision making process. Thus, the study contributes to the science of ecosystem assessment.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,PEMBANGUNAN EKONOMI BERKELANJUTAN,PERUBAHAN IKLIM,TEKNIK PENGAMBILAN KEPUTUSAN MULTI KRITERIA

Evaluasi kebijakan ekonomi tentang Pameran Aichi 2005 dari sudut pandang strategi perusahaan. (E 182011-5 anp)

It is difficult to give a rational basis the "Aichi Exposition 2005". As one of the methods which aim at people's agreement formation to the strategic event, a multiple-purpose evaluation method seems to be possible to evaluate from the viewpoint of corporate strategy. This paper describes the rationality of the venues of the "Aichi Exposition 2005" by using the AHP from the theory of corporate strategy. The criteria were extracted from the viewpoint of the corporate strategy, alternative was each heartland region of eight an economic block as for the Japanese whole country, and the priority was evaluated by the absolute measurements method. Moreover the AHP was attempted to extend to the ANP, then the results showed that eigenvalue method is superior to Super Matrix method in the diagonal matrix to all one. At the end of the paper it was pointed out that Aichi led to the best for the venue and the economic policy needed to change.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,EXSPOSITION 2005,JURNAL ANP,KEBIJAKAN EKONOMI,MULTI KRITERIA,STRATEGI PERUSAHAAN

STUDI TENTANG PEMANFAATAN KOMPATIBILITAS METRIC DI AHP: MENERAPKAN UNTUK PENILAIAN PROSES PERANGKAT LUNAK. (E 182011-4 anp)

This study intends to extend the applicability of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) to software process assessments. Recently an AHP approach has been successfully applied to software process assessments especially with regard to boundary problems, ambiguities between two adjacent ratings. Boundary problems may cause a problem in the process of inter-rater agreement for a process attribute rating among assessors. However, the approach assumes that the assessors reach a consensus for priorities of the associated practices. When assessors cannot reach a priority consensus, a more systematic method is required to make a consensus among those assessors having different sets of priorities. In order to solve this problem, this study proposes a consolidating method among conflicting assessors using compatibility metric of the AHP, and shows its application step.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,KOMPATIBILITAS,PENGAMBILAN KEPUTUSAN KELOMPOK,PROSES PENILAIAN PERANGKAT LUNAK,RESOLUSI KONFLIK

PENDEKATAN TERPADU UNTUK MEMPERKIRAKAN PERMINTAAN HOTEL. (E 182011-3 anp)

 It was aimed to search to be able to forecast the crises which arise from demand fluctuations, and to able to generate a systematic and dynamic process in the hotel businesses. In the quantitative period, forecasting was realized to 149 monthly series of a five star hotel in Ankara via MA, Simple, Holt's, Winter's Exponential Smoothing and ARIMA. The results of these methods were compared by some error measures. At the other side of integration, two Delphi based inquiry panels were realized: The Variables Determination Panel and The Environmental Monitoring Panel. The opinions of second group panelists were used to adjust Winter's Multiplicative forecasts via AHP based approach. This process shows that, if the forecasting and adjustment process is applied to hotels monthly, it will be useful for crises arised from demand fluctuations in hotelbusiness. The most important characteristic of model is being elasticity for change and development.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,DELPHI,JURNAL ANP,PENYESUAIAN,PERKIRAAN,PERMINTAAN HOTEL

PENELITIAN PENERAPAN ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS UNTUK PENDEKATAN ROADMAPPING TEKNOLOGI. (E 182011-2 anp)

Roadmapping Teknologi adalah alat untuk perencanaan teknologi di bidang akademik dan industri. Dalam tulisan ini,pertama, kita meringkas teknis masalah yang muncul dalam roadmapping teknologi. Kemudian, kami menunjukkan sebuah metodologi berdasarkan  Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) untuk mengatasi masalah pengambilan keputusan dalam mengevaluasi

teknologi alternatif dalam peta jalan teknologi.  

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,PENGAMBILAN KEPUTUSAN KELOMPOK,ROADMAPPING TEKNOLOGI

Memberdayakan Analytic Hierarchy Process dengan Konsep Domain Kebiasaan. (E182011-1 anp)

Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP dan ANP) telah menyediakan cara yang efisien bagi orang untuk memperingkat prioritas kriteria dan alternatif secara numerik. Memanfaatkan konsep domain kebiasaan, kita akan mencoba untuk menjelaskan fenomena mengapa AHP dan ANP banyak dipakai dan bagaimana untuk lebih memberdayakan AHP dan ANP dalam teori dan aplikasi sebagai arena untuk memecahkan masalah keputusan praktis dan kompleks secara lebih efektif.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,KONSEP DOMAIN KEBIASAAN

Seleksi Vendor Sofware Menggunakan Fuzzy Analytic Hirarki Proses dengan ISO / IEC 9126. (E 6.+software anp)

Makalah ini mengusulkan Model Fuzzy Analytic Hirarki Proses dengan ISO / IEC 9126  pemilihan vendor perangkat lunak. Kriteria kualitas perangkat lunak mengadopsi norma internasional ISO/IEC9126-1: 2001 yang meliputi enam kriteria yang terdiri dari dari 27 subcriteria. Metode prioritas dari Model Fuzzy AHP  menerapkan Logaritma Fuzzy Kuadrat Terkecil (LLSM). Model yang diusulkan dapat membantu pengembang dan penguji untuk mengevaluasi aplikasi perangkat lunak vendor dan memilih alternatif terbaik dalam lingkungan yang tidak pasti.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,FUZZY AHP,JURNAL ANP,PENGAMBILAN KEPUTUSAN MODEL FUZZY,SELEKSI VENDOR SOFTWARE

Perbandingan Metode ANP dan AHP dalam Penentuan Prioritas Multi Respons Metode Taguchi. (E01 anp)

Studi ini mempelajari masalah pemberian prioritas kepada dua atau lebih karakter kualitas yang dihadapi sambil menerapkan Metode Taguchi pada masalah multiresponse. Ini didasarkan pada Tong dkk (1997) 's. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) dan Analytic Network Process(ANP)  digunakan untuk menetapkan prioritas karakteristik kualitas produk automative .Perbandingan dilakukan antara hasil yang diperoleh oleh AHP dan  ANP.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,JURNAL MANAJEMEN,KARAKTERISTIK KUALITAS PRODUK OTOMOTIF,METODE TAGUCHI,MULTI RESPON

Peningkatan Kinerja Hubungan Pembeli dan Pemasok Menggunakan AHP dan GSS. (E20 ahp)

Peningkatan persaingan global secara keseluruhan mendorong perusahaan untuk meningkatkan kinerja bisnis mereka terus menerus dalam setiap sektor. Pemanfaatan sumber daya eksternal, termasuk jaringan pemasok, telah menjadi salah satu daerah pengembangan yang paling penting dari bisnis, yang membutuhkan banyak perhatian. Dalam tulisan ini, hubungan kinerja pembeli-pemasok akan ditingkatkan dengan menggunakan metode benchmarking dalam membantu identifikasi dan pelaksanaan kegiatan pembangunan yang diperlukan untukmencapai tingkat kelas dunia. Proses pembandingan akan dilakukan dengan dua sistem pendukung keputusan: AHP dan GSS.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS,GSS,JURNAL ANP,JURNAL MANAJEMEN,KINERJA HUBUNGAN PEMBELI-PEMASOK,SISTEM PENDUKUNG KEPUTUSAN

Studi Perbaikan Metode Pelelangan Elektronik Berulang (Reverse E-Auction). (INA01 anp)

Reverse e-auction adalah metode pelelangan barang dan jasa secara elektronik yang saat ini populer digunakan karena menghasilkan penghematan biaya, efisiensi proses, murah dan transparan. Dalam lelang berbasis internet ini hanya harga sebagai atribut y ang dapat dinegosiasikan. E-auction dapat menimbulkan kerugian apabila digunakan dalam kondisi yang tidak tepat. Studi kasus dengan metode Analytic Network Process di PT. X mengungkapkan kekurangan pengadaan barang dan jasa metode reverse e-auction dan merekomendasikan atribut harga, pengiriman, dan kualitas produk sebagai pertimbangan yang mempunyai bobot signifikan. Sementara itu atribut. kualitas manajemen pemasok merupakan atribut yang berperan sebagai pertimbangan awal.

Read more »

Posted in: ANALYTIC NETWORK PROCESS,JURNAL ANP,JURNAL KEBIJAKAN,JURNAL MANAJEMEN,PENGADAAN BARANG DAN JASA